Here‘s a ranking of the ten best keepers in Serie A this season- the criteria is strictly performances in league play, not reputation nor ability
When you consider how long he has been in our lives, it’s hard to believe that Milan’s keeper is just twenty years old. After a very tumultuous season following a very acrimonious negotiation for his contract extension. Donnarumma has fully rebounded and is now the gold standard at the position in Serie A especially when you consider his improvements with ball distribution.
Along with Romagnoli, Donnarumma is the main reason Milan’s defense has been the best in Serie A in 2019. In addition to his performances for the rossoneri, Donnarumma has fully established himself as the heir to Gigi Buffon on the Azzurri- no easy feat.
The former Paris St Germain keeper broke Torino’s record for longest streak without conceding a goal, a very impressive achievement if you know about Torino’s history. While it’s easier to get excited for younger keepers and Sirigu doesn’t get much attention because Torino isn’t a sexy team like Atalanta or even Sampdoria, he has consistently been in conversation for best keeper in Serie A performance wise even before his impressive recent streak.
Cagliari’s keeper has been a staple of the Italian national’s team youth teams in recent years despite facing significant competition at his position and in his second season as a full time starter in Serie A, he has more than lived up to the hype.
What Cragno may lack in height (at least compared to the other top keepers in the league) he more than makes up with his reflexes and positioning- because of his body type and ability, he has been compared to former Juventus keeper Angelo Peruzzi. Cragno is ready to take the next step at a big club and could be a target for both Roma where he could be an immediate starter next season and Inter where he could be more of a long term replacement for Handanovic.
After making name for himself at Venezia in Serie B last season, the former Juventus youth team product has excelled at Sampdoria after replacing veteran Emiliano Viviano. Audero’s performances for Marco Giampaolo’s side have already caught the eye of Arsenal, who have scouted him multiple times after hitting a homerun with Lucas Torreira who arrived to London from Sampdoria.
While a lot was made about Ferrero’s club spending twenty million euro to acquire him on a permanent basis from Juventus last week, anyone who watched him regularly is much less outraged than say the fees paid for Sturaro and Cerri- considering Audero’s age and ability, he could be sold for a considerably amount in the near future.
It might surprise those who mainly know him from his time at Arsensal, but there’s no doubt the Polish international has been one of the best keepers in Italy the past four years. The main reason he isn’t higher in this ranking is that this specific season his best performances have come in the Champions League, but he has erased any doubt he’s a worthy heir to Buffon at Juventus and he has decisively won his current competition with newly acquired Mattia Perin.
After appearing in just one Serie A match the past three seasons, the former Napoli keeper has exceled at Parma. Sepe is a bit of a late bloomer since he’ll turn 28 at the beginning of May, but his performances for D’Aversa’s side have been as impactful of Gervinho and as a result he’s ready to be a starter for years to come.
After years of being underrated (at least outside of Serie A) mainly because he had never played in the Champions League or the starter on a high profile national team, maybe I’m taking Inter’s new captain for granted with this rating. But Handanovic has continued to be the definition of a feast or famine keeper, he can make saves that maybe no one else on the list can get to but is also the leader of mistakes that are reminiscent of when the battery of the controller on your PS4 runs out of juice mid game.
Napoli’s keeper would certainly be either third or fourth on this list had he not missed so many games to start the season because of a shoulder injury. Ancelotti has rightfully been cautious since he returned by rotating him with Ospina, but despite not playing in every match, the former Udinese keeper has shown why Italy’s Under 19 goalkeeper coach Ferron once said he considers Meret just as good a prospect as Donnarumma. Meret was picked to replace Pepe Reina at Napoli also because of his ball distribution skills and so far has shown he’ll be a much better shot stopper than his predecessor in the near future (if he isn’t already).
Chievo maybe dead last in the standings but that is certainly not because of the performances of their soon to be 40 year old keeper. Sorrentino was the first keeper to stop one of Ronaldo’s penalties and will certainly be able to find a job in Serie A next season should he decide to keep playing.
Those who only know the French keeper from FIFA must be surprised to see him ranked this low, but while Lafont has certainly made many numerous spectacular saves since arriving in Tuscany, he has also shown some significant limitations in every aspect of his role outside of shot stopping (he’s essentially the French Mattia Perin). But considering his young age and physical tools we can expect him to improve significantly next season.